5 whys and root cause analysis: a practical guide

By John M Slater

When something goes wrong, the first answer is rarely the real one. The 5 whys is one of the simplest ways to dig deeper and find out why an incident really happened, so you fix the cause and not just the symptom. Here's how to use it well, and when you need more.

What is the 5 whys?

The 5 whys is a root cause technique. You start with the problem and ask "why did this happen?" Then you take the answer and ask "why?" again, and keep going until you reach a cause that, if fixed, would stop the problem coming back. Five is a guide, not a rule. Sometimes you get there in three, sometimes it takes seven.

How to run a 5 whys

  1. 1.Write down the problem clearly. Describe what happened, not who did it. "The pump failed and leaked oil" is better than "the technician didn't check the pump".
  2. 2.Get the right people in the room. Include the people who do the work. They know how things really happen.
  3. 3.Ask why, and test each answer with evidence. Every answer should be backed by facts: records, photos, interviews, data. If you can't prove it, keep looking.
  4. 4.Keep going until you reach something you can fix. Stop when you reach a cause in your systems, processes or decisions that you can change.
  5. 5.Agree actions and check they work. A root cause is only useful if the action that follows actually stops it happening again.

A worked example

Problem: a worker slipped on an oily walkway and sprained an ankle.

Why did they slip? There was oil on the walkway.

Why was there oil on the walkway? A pump seal had been leaking for several days.

Why had the leak not been fixed? It had been reported, but the repair was sitting in the maintenance backlog.

Why was it in the backlog? Leaks were all given the same low priority, whatever the hazard.

Why? The way maintenance work is prioritised doesn't consider safety risk.

The root cause is not "the worker didn't look where they were going". It's a prioritisation process that doesn't account for safety. Fix that, and you prevent many future incidents, not just this one.

Common mistakes

  • Stopping at human error. "Someone made a mistake" is where an investigation should start, not finish. Ask why the mistake was possible and why it wasn't caught.
  • Following only one chain. Most incidents have several causes. Run more than one line of whys.
  • Guessing instead of checking. Every answer needs evidence.
  • Looking for someone to blame. Good investigations seek systematic improvements, not to get people. If people fear blame, they stop telling you the truth.
  • Ignoring the warning signs. In every serious incident I've investigated, there were signs that were seen and not acted on. Ask what was known before it happened.

When you need more than 5 whys

The 5 whys is excellent for simpler problems and for building a curious, learning culture. For serious or complex incidents you need more structure: a detailed timeline, analysis of which barriers failed and why, and techniques that capture several causes at once. That's where trained investigators make the difference.

Learn from what went right, too

Every investigation also finds things that worked: a good decision under pressure, a barrier that held, a person who spoke up. Ask why those went right, and build them into how you work.

Common questions

Is the 5 whys enough for a serious incident?
On its own, usually not. It's a useful part of a wider investigation, but serious incidents need a more structured approach led by trained investigators.
Who should take part in a 5 whys?
The people closest to the work, someone who can facilitate without leading the answers, and someone with the authority to act on what you find.
How do I train my team to investigate thoroughly?
Through practical training at the right level for each role. I train people from awareness level through to lead investigator, online and on site.

Want your team to investigate thoroughly? I train people at every level, from awareness to lead investigator, online and on site, in the UK and worldwide.